Tuesday, September 11, 2007

SPECIAL GUEST POST:REVIEW by my daughter, Petunia



For the last MotherTalk review I am on-schedule to do for a while, I decided to get my sweet-sweet Petunia to assist and post a guest review all her own of The Dark Dreamweaver, the Juvenile-fiction book by Nick Ruth. For me, any novel that can get a dialogue going between a mother and her (almost) eleven-year-old daughter is a very good thing. With The Dark Dreamweaver, we discussed nightmares and monarch butterflies, problem-solving, magic, and mystery over cups of tea and the most indulgent desserts possible at our local cafe. What follows is Petunia's un-altered take on this, the first book of The Remin Chronicles series.

*************************************************************************************
The Dark Dreamweaver is a very descriptive and creative book in which fantasy and reality are tied together creating one world. The characters themselves were filled with individuality. Mr. Ruth invented creatures that are astounding to me, such as the physical structure of Aradel and Sir Heads-a-Lot. The plot of The Dark Dreamweaver reminded me of other stories with children going into magic worlds, however, this book has its own twists and personality. The little caterpillar who seemed only slightly different from the others reveals himself to David as a wizard under an evil spell who needs assistance to save Remin, the magical home of dreams.

I feel The Dark Dreamweaver worked because it was interesting how Monarch butterflies starred in the world of magic and Remin. In addition, the few scary parts made me look all around my room as I read before sleep, searching for wicked faces or strange serpents. I learned new things about butterflies, which, for me, completed the story in a very interesting way. The final section of The Dark Dreamweaver was full of useful reference information about hatching your own Monarchs and gave me very interesting websites to learn more facts about butterfly gardening as well. I also highly enjoyed the ending of this book, and how David's cats ended up playing a role in saving him from the evil Thane.

In the beginning, this novel had a lot of drama, which kept the reader gripped, but the charm faded slightly as the story unfolded. Some of the wandering in the middle of the book could have been shortened a bit because it took up too many pages. In the end, though, the battle and conclusion zap action back into the story like a bolt of lightning. Also, since I believe that nature is a very important thing in this (and every) world, I adored the fact that the back cover mentions that "5% of all the net proceeds from The Dark Dreamweaver will be donated to help reforest the Monarch butterfly overwintering sites". In conclusion, I would recommend The Dark Dreamweaver to my friends because the novel offered the elements I always look for in a good story: drama, excitement, and magic.
*************************************************************************************Reviewer Bio Note:
Petunia Moon is a very bookish young lady who will turn eleven on October 19th. She loves hiking, star-gazing, and anything that will take her outside in nature--where she says "her spirit lives". Though for many years, she wanted to be a marine biologist, currently she is interested in a career in the arts or possibly as a psychologist since she recently has become fascinated with the structure and chemistry of the human brain. She mystifies her mother on an hourly basis and I want to thank her, sincerely, for how seriously she took this review-writing process!

Labels: ,

Link

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Clicked my way over from the MotherTalk site and wanted to say thank you to Petunia for a great review!

Bella G.

10:56 AM  
Blogger daisies said...

what a wonderful review ~ i know a someone who will be getting this as a gift now :) thank you petunia!

12:04 PM  
Blogger Michelle (a.k.a. la vie en rose) said...

i love that the two of your read the same book and then talked about it...that's fabulous!

2:49 PM  
Anonymous Nick Ruth said...

As the author of this,my first book I love to read reviews written by the audience for which the story was intended. Thanks Petunia.

This book and the sequel "The Breezes of Inspire" had three distinct parts while I was writing them. Part one plunges the reader into the story and gets them to the beginning of their journey. Part two takes the adventurers from point A (part one) to point B (part three) and part three is the climax and wrap-up. For me it's easy to write the beginning and the end but the middle always is a struggle and I obviously failed to make it as interesting as the other two parts. Hopefully I've done better with the sequel.

10:14 PM  
Anonymous Marjorie said...

Petunia, you did a fantastic job on this review! What a thoughtful reader and writer you are ... thank you for sharing your impressions!

1:03 AM  
Anonymous kimberley said...

Bravisimo Petunia Moon!

I have always enjoyed reading your mom's blog. Now I can add you to some of my favorite blog reading.

1:33 AM  
Blogger Lacithecat said...

Excellent Review!

3:17 AM  
Blogger Left-handed Trees... said...

Bella G: thank you!

daisies: she did enjoy reading this one, no doubt about that.

michelle: it was a delicious writing/reading date--we do them a couple of times each month.

nick ruth: she is going to be so excited that you stopped by and read her review! I know she is looking forward to reading the subsequent books to see where David ends up next.

marjorie: thank you. She was delighted to be a part of the review process!

kimberely: she even had her own blog for a while, but hasn't updated in a long time. I know she has some new poems she's been writing, so they may land there soon.

lacithecat: thank you!

10:19 AM  
Blogger Amber said...

How wonderful!

:)

4:07 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 License.